Endless dancing
Red Shoes (Boots) modelled by Power Ranger Jason Lee ScottFairy tales often conceal dark thoughts and fears. Frequently, they’re based on unpleasant and unpalatable facts, and are used as moral fables.
The Brothers Grimm wrote the story of Snow White in 1812, though it traces its origins to earlier folk tales in which a mother wished for a beautiful child, ‘’with skin as white as snow, lips as red as blood, and hair as black as ebony.”
In Snow White the lovely child was born and adored, but her loving mother died soon after the baby’s birth. Her father married a beautiful woman who was excessively vain and despised the pretty little girl. Many times, she sought to kill her, but each time her efforts were thwarted.
After the trials and tribulations visited upon the poor child by her stepmother, Snow White was awoken from her living death and married her handsome prince. The evil stepmother was invited to the wedding, but was overcome with envy and hatred at seeing the lovely young woman, who had displaced her as “the fairest in all the land.” Her wickedness was repaid with a curse. She was compelled to wear a pair of shoes of red-hot iron and dance until she collapsed and died.
Evil is as evil does, you might say.
A little more than thirty years later, Hans Christian Andersen wrote The Red Shoes in 1845.
If you have ever wondered why ‘Karen’ became a pejorative term for rude, privileged women, the clue may lie within the story. It wasn’t adopted as an insult until the twenty-first century, after an unpleasant incident in Central Park, New York.
In defence of Karens everywhere, I have known several by that name, all perfectly pleasant.
In the story, poor orphaned Karen was adopted by a wealthy lady and indulged in everything, growing up spoilt and conceited. Spotting a pretty pair of red shoes in a cobbler’s shop window, Karen could not rest until she acquired them. Once in possession of them, she could not bear to remove them.
Dressed in white for her confirmation, she refused to change them for something more appropriate, greatly upsetting those around her, particularly her guardian. Later, as her guardian lay seriously ill Karen wore the shoes to a ball, giving little heed to the woman who had taken her in and looked after her.
To her shock, as she left the ball, she found herself dancing and unable to stop. An angel appeared and told her she was cursed to wear the shoes and dance through all eternity. In desperation, Karen begged for her feet to be chopped off, and they danced away from her. She was then given wooden feet and crutches, and lived the rest of her life humbly.
That is a profound object lesson.
There are shades of eternal dancing in the Pied Piper of Hamelin, another story written by the Brothers Grimm. It is a strange tale that has its roots in history.
After the Pied Piper had been cheated of his agreed fee for ridding the town of Hamelin of its plague of rats, he took his revenge by enticing the children to follow him out of the town. The children could not resist the strains of the Piper’s tunes, and danced away to a lair in the mountains, never to be seen again. One poor crippled boy, unable to keep up with his companions, was left behind to tell the tale.
As always, there are several versions of the story, but there is a street in Hamelin which is said to be the last place the children were seen alive before they disappeared. It is called ‘Bungelosenstrasse,’ (street without drums) and no music or dancing is ever allowed on that thoroughfare.
You can't beat traditional fairy stories for horror!
ReplyDeleteTrue!
DeleteThe Grimm fairy tales lived up to their name. There was not so much 'happily ever after'.
ReplyDeleteThey were all pretty much of the good versus evil, with evil being defeated.
DeleteOur poor children, fairy tales, nursery rhymes, all with horrible undertones.
ReplyDeleteThey sing them and chant them with the innocence of childhood.
DeleteThose tales gave me nightmares as a child 😱
ReplyDeleteI think the idea was to learn from the mistakes made by the 'evil' characters . . .
DeleteI do remember being scared reading some of these as a child. Today I can see them being the basis of horror movies with the usual embellishments.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you.
DeleteI know that many fairy tales I read as a child were, shall we say, edited to take out most of the gore, but they were still frightening. I should go back and read the unedited versions. This was an interesting followup on your post about uncontrollable dancing.
ReplyDeleteThey were certainly sanitised for children, but retained enough horror to frighten.
DeleteYou make fascinating connections between the stories and modernity here. These details also reminded me of some girls I went to middle school with whose religion did not allow them to dance. I think that puritanical notion might be connected too as in limiting freedoms and then disparaging said freedoms to maintain control. The oldest stories are indeed like nesting dolls.
ReplyDeleteNesting dolls is a very good analogy.
DeleteNot being allowed to dance is denying people freedom to express joy.
These timeless tales remind us that beneath their enchantment lie enduring moral warnings about vanity, greed, and the consequences of human folly
ReplyDeleteAbsolutely - listen and learn.
DeleteI read quite a few compilations of original fairy tales as a tween, and was shocked at how different they were from the Disney tales I was used to.
ReplyDeleteDisney managed to make them quite sweet and acceptable, with just enough horror to thrill.
DeleteThat is a new take on Snow White for me. I didn't know that.
ReplyDeleteIt isn't in most children's versions of the story.
DeleteThe original fairy tales were often quite grim.
ReplyDeleteThey were - rape and pillage, theft and murder - not what we like our children to read about.
DeleteI know the story of Snow White well but never heard the part about the stepmother and the shoes of red hot iron
ReplyDeleteThat's left out of children's stories.
DeleteNasty story by the Brothers Grimm.
ReplyDeleteNasty times, in many ways.
DeleteI never read these Fairy tales to my kids, we read different kid stories.
ReplyDeleteI'm sure they're better for it.
DeleteOf course as a child in Germany, I knew my Grimms Märchen inside out, and found nearly all of them quite horrible and scary. Pushing a woman (even if she's a witch) into a burnig oven? Shutting up someone in a tower for 100 years? Hot iron shoes that kill you? Poisoned apples, kidnapping and all sorts of cruel stuff? Yes, the Good usually wins over the Bad in those tales, but at what price!
ReplyDeleteAnyway, I didn't know the name Karen was associated with rude, privileged women; it certainly isn't here, and like you, I know some very nice Karens who are neither privileged nor rude.
The punishments for evildoing in the stories perhaps reflected the treatment of criminals, even petty criminals, at the time - whipping, branding, public humiliation in stocks or pillory, hard labour, incarceration. Harsh times.
DeleteSome fairy tales are indeed very dark.
ReplyDeleteThey are, and hide all sorts of abuse.
DeleteNot stories meant for bedtime reading for children.
ReplyDelete. . . at least, only the sanitised versions.
DeleteSome folk tales are seriously disturbing.
ReplyDeleteThey are, and are reflective of the times in which they were written.
DeleteThe final part of Snow White's step mother dancing until she died was left out of any story I've read. Political correctness gone mad, back in the 1960s. This was a nice segue from yesterday's St Vitus Dance post.
ReplyDeleteIt's quite horrible.
DeleteThank you.
I have read the Disney version on Snow White to my children many times but not to the grandchildren. I guess it fell out of favour. We had quite a collection of the Disney tales if I recall correctly. Fond memories.
ReplyDeleteThe gentle versions are generally acceptable if not pursued too rigorously.
DeleteWell I went on a rabbit hole descent to remember a story from childhood. Then it came, 'The Snow Queen' by Hans Christien Anderson. Gerda danced for the queen so that her brother Kai could be rid of the ice in his heart.
ReplyDeleteThat wasn't the gentlest of tales, either, was it?
DeleteInteresting. I think I prefer the “happily ever after” from the Disney versions better.
ReplyDeleteThey are certainly gentler, with just a little frisson of fear.
DeleteI used to have a book of Hans Christian Anderson fairy tales with quite lurid illustrations when I was growing up, and always skipped The Red Shoes as I found it quite horrible. I had in fact been wondering about the Karen thing ... xxx
ReplyDeleteIt clearly made an impact on you.
ReplyDeleteI was interested to find out about the origin of 'Karen' as an insult, too.
Folk tales are pretty Grim(M) at times!!!
ReplyDeleteI just read a great trilogy based on the Pied Piper of Hamelin and the aftermath. Such a clever series by S. A. Patrick!