Tuesday, 15 October 2024

Differences

 

Differences

 

Arthur sleeps!

    There are many differences between working Labradors and Cocker Spaniels.

The most obvious difference is size. Labradors are bigger, between 25 and 38 kg. I’ve just discovered that working Labradors are known in the States as American or field-bred Labradors. British working Labradors are field-bred dogs from the UK and Ireland.

Working Cocker spaniels weigh 11 to 16 kg and are between 36 to 43 cm at the withers, which I have to remind myself is the highest point of the shoulder blades. Compare that to a Labrador standing 54 to 62 cm. at the same point.

Labradors are relaxed, steady dogs, though they do have their wild moments. Generally, well-exercised and well-fed dogs will settle down at your feet and snore sleep the hours away. Cockers are busy, fizzy little dogs. They are anxious to please and will greet their owners with enthusiasm and at least one toy in their mouths. Labradors are equally delighted to see their people and are keen to nose them and give them a good sniffing to discover where they’ve been and with whom.

When they’re outside, a cocker’s nose is never far from the ground if it’s not scenting the air. Labradors like to read the environment as well, but they’re not so keen to seek prey. That’s not their job. They are required to pick up, though they will sometimes spring birds or rabbits.

Both breeds love water and are drawn to it as to a magnet.

The biggest difference is in their approach to food. All Labradors – at least, all the many ones we’ve had, love food, and most of them live to eat, whereas cockers eat to live, from our limited experience of them.

When Arthur comes to play, we have to persuade him to eat, even when it’s obvious he’s hungry. Like a restless child, he is easily distracted from eating, whereas the Labradors plough straight through the food until there’s not a hint of a scent of anything left, and then look around with a half-starved expression, hoping to convince any passing human in the house that they really have not been fed for days.

Both breeds are great friends, like all dogs.

Jake

Dogs are wonderful companions, no matter what their provenance, and some of the best are rescue dogs looking for their forever homes. One of the loveliest dogs I ever knew was Jake, an absolute peach of a dog.

Of unknown breeding, he was delighted to be accepted and loved by my daughter and son-in-law. He was an amazingly loyal and loving dog to them and their children. When they acquired a Labrador puppy, and we went to see them, he would jump into the back of our car, hoping to come home with us. He liked the puppy but sometimes wanted a rest from her. All puppies are exhausting for a while and Jake enjoyed a quiet life. As the puppy grew up and calmed down, Jake became very fond of her.

There is always an unknown quality in rescue dogs. Unless they are very young puppies in a rescue centre, there is no knowing what has befallen them in their lives. It’s too easy to be led by the heart, rather than reason.

 Rescue societies do a grand job of assessing them and advising to the best of their ability whether a dog will settle with young children, or cats, or more than one or two people. The best rescue centres will interview prospective owners and will not release a dog unless and until they are satisfied that the dog is going to a good home and will not be returned in a few weeks when the novelty has worn off.

We don’t deserve dogs, really.                        

39 comments:

  1. I remember labradors that ate everything in sight including things they shouldn't. I've never known a dog that needed coaxing to eat unless it was recovering from an illness or surgery.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I prefer dogs with a greed - they're easier to look after, to train, and to know when there's something wrong!

      Delete
  2. I agree. All Labradors love food, and most of them live to eat. This makes encouraging and rewarding labbies easy. But it makes them very fat.
    I have never had a cocker since my own childhood but I can see them at the coffee shop, sitting quietly next to their owners.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We have to be strict with our dogs' diets or they would quickly get fat. We should be stricter with our own diets . . .

      Delete
  3. We see a lot of working cockers doing dog agility and they can all run raster than Nobby and tend to be very successful. Labradors don't feature too much in the agility world, perhaps because they have less innate drive.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Labradors aren't really built to run and it's not good for their joints. I can believe that the cockers excel at agility. We had a Dalmatian who was quite good at agility for a while with my enthusiastic youngest daughter.

      Delete
  4. Some people don't deserve any animals, I've had 7 cats in my adult life, we never had cats as a child just dogs. I can't wait until our next ball of fluff arrives at Christmas time, for now we can dream of all the fun.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Having a new kitten or puppy is like welcoming a new baby into the family. Have you decided on a name yet?

      Delete
  5. You write almost every topic with passion and good in depth research. Love this article

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's generous of you to say. Thank you.

      Delete
  6. Replies
    1. That's all right - I won't hold it against you. 😺

      Delete
  7. I see so many of the very same dogs being walked by their humans on the bike path. Sometimes I stop to say hello and find out their names are what breed they are. Lots of others I just wave and go on because it's obvious they're human is trying to hang on for dear life because the dog is ready to run.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We always know the dogs' names but hardly ever the owners' names. Some dogs like to take their owners for a walk, rather than the other way round.

      Delete
  8. We've never had any type of spaniel, they always seem hugely energetic that's for sure. In my limited experience of dog ownership I have learned that terriers don't make for a peaceful life 😉but they are often very comical ( I'm sure there are exceptions.......) and labs - once they are past the puppy stage are the most wonderful and relaxing companion. We often encourage each other to chill out and " be more Labrador " 😀
    Lovely photos
    Alison in Wales x

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I had a Springer spaniel when I was a girl. He was lovely but a wanderer. We had Jack Russells for a long time and they were very entertaining, sometimes in the wrong way. They are big dogs in little dogs' bodies and not at all relaxing, but great characters. Labradors are reliable and gentle and just lovely in every way.

      Delete
  9. Even though Husband says no I still keep looking on rescue sites. So many of the dogs sound wonderful but there's always a but. Can't be an only dog, not suitable around children, etc. One day maybe. Daughter has a sprocker. Holly is crazy!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. My grandson has a Romanian rescue dog. She has worked out very well and they now have a Labrador as well, and a toddler. I've met a few Romanian rescues round here - for some reason they're popular in this area.

      Delete
  10. Nooooo! Not Holly. She was their last dog. Louie I mean.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Arthur and Jake are beautiful dogs. I agree, we don't really deserve dogs. They are such good dear creatures.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They are very accepting, no matter how badly they may be treated. It makes my heart bleed.

      Delete
  12. As the saying goes a dog is for life and not just Christmas ... perhaps even more important for folks to realise this with Christmas getting closer.
    Lovely photographs of Arthur and Jake.

    All the best Jan

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I do so agree. Christmas is quite the wrong time to take in a new baby pet, unless you're very experienced.

      Delete
  13. I didn't know that cockers were workers, and I am still not sure what they worked at. I like dogs well enough but prefer to live with cats.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Not all cockers are working dogs, just the cockers bred for working in the field.. They flush out the game from dense undergrowth and hedgerows. It is instinctive in the working lines, just as instinctive as it is for a field-bred Labrador to retrieve.

      Delete
  14. Oh Janice, I love this post, I love the woofies, and spot on descriptions of the breeds. Many years ago I knew a couple who bred labradors. When I first visited I wondered why their kitchen looked derelict. I didn't know dogs could do that much damage - the lower walls didn't have any plaster on them and they had chewed the lino!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh, yes, that sounds right. Puppies need a lot of looking after if you want your house to last.

      Delete
  15. I agree - they are the most wonderful companions - we had 2 working cocker spaniels on the farm & they were amazing. Sue the eldest one, we could say Go & get the cows Sue (we could leave the gate open in the mornings, as they stayed in the paddock) & off she would go to the far reaches of the farm while the Mr had a cuppa. She would walk the cows all the way to the cowshed, just quietly not running, & we always knew if Sue didn't come out of the paddock then there was a cow down, or stuck in a drain .. so we could go & check. She was the most amazing farm dog but also a beloved family member. xx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That is a wonderful story. What a sweet dog she must have been. They are so bright.

      Delete
  16. I forgot to say -that was Julie @ mythreadbearlife who is still having computer issues (!!!)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. the anonymous comment above I meant ... oh gosh (!!)

      Delete
    2. Computers are great, until they aren't!

      Delete
  17. We had one rescue dog of mixed breeding who would eat like there was no tomorrow, the other a small purebred, only seemed to eat because she knew if she didn't, the other dog would eat her food. She was a slow but not a picky eater.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's funny to watch an unenthusiastic eater when another threatens to steal the food!

      Delete
  18. I take my hat off to all the cat and dog rescue charities that do such an amazing job to find the best forever home for them.
    I love the photos of Jake and Arthur.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Their work must be heartbreaking at times.

      Delete



Thank you for visiting. I love to read your comments and really appreciate you taking the time to respond to posts.

I will always try to repay your visit whenever possible.