Friday, 11 April 2025

Stick or cane?

 

Stick or cane?

What I call a walking stick is more accurately referred to as a cane, as Red from Hiawatha House pointed out, backed up by Anvil Cloud and Mad Snapper N Beau. My impression is that North Americans are inclined to call them canes. Mostly, I use walking poles, just to confuse matters.

I found this explanation: ‘ . . . although the words "walking stick" and "walking cane" are often used to mean the same thing . . .  there can be distinctions between the two. A walking stick, especially one with a novelty handle, is designed more for use as a fashion accessory but may still provide some stability and balance whilst walking for shorter periods of times, while a walking cane is designed for regular everyday use as a mobility aid to support your full body weight and take the pressure off.

I wanted to know the correct terminology for the anatomy of a walking aid. (See how neatly I avoided the problem of using the right label?)

There are four main parts to a walking cane: handle, collar, shaft and ferrule. The handle can take many forms. It may be a knob, which is not very comfortable for walking and is probably more for show, a carved head, an ergonomic design, or a crook, with many variations in between.

This one is a simple Derby handle on my decades-old folding walking stick.

Ergonomic handle (right hand)

The collar hides the joint between the handle and the shaft, strengthening the bond. Sometimes the collar is intricately decorated. 

                    Adjustable shaft on my carbon walking pole

The shaft is the length of the cane from handle to ferrule. It may be made from any strong, load-bearing material, from beechwood to carbon fibre and many materials besides. The length of the shaft is important: too short and the walker will stoop, too tall and the user may suffer neck and shoulder problems.

                                                    Rubber ferrule

On the end of the shaft is the ferrule, which may be rubber or metal, and adapted for different surfaces. A spiked ferrule is useful in rough terrain, but dangerous on polished floors. A rubber ferrule provides peace of mind and stability on a slippery surface. For further stability, a user may opt for a tripod or tetrapod stick.

                                 Image courtesy Wikimedia Commons

Sticks come in many guises, from the everyday aid to the ceremonial.

The shepherd’s crook was a useful tool as well as a defensive weapon. The curved hook was used to help in recovering animals from danger, catching them by the neck or leg. As a sturdy support, it aided the shepherd in his travels across sometimes rough ground, and provided him with a useful stave to fend off predators.

In the form of a bishop’s crozier, it has been used by high-ranking religious leaders to symbolise the leadership and pastoral care of their congregation or ‘flock.’ A crozier is traditionally much taller than a shepherd’s crook, perhaps to be more readily seen by the congregation.

Some countryside walkers opt for thumb sticks. These are made from woods like hazel and have a v-shaped section of wood or antler in which to slot the thumb.

Another form of stick is the shooting stick, which combines a folding seat with a walking stick. It is a useful for short-term seating at outdoor events, or to provide a swift perch when out walking and needing a rest.

An Irish walking stick is called a shillelagh. It is often made from blackthorn and is a traditional symbol of Irish heritage and a formidable weapon, though not principally used as such in modern times.

Modern sword sticks, a hollow walking stick concealing a sharp blade, are considered offensive weapons and it is illegal to carry them in public, although antique examples are exempt, which is odd, as even an old blade can be sharpened and used for nefarious means.

It is important that any walking or trekking stick is the appropriate height for the user. Many modern sticks are adjustable, but those in which the shaft is made from a single piece of wood must be tailored to the user.

Some sticks are foldable and a useful alternative for people who need to use a walking stick only occasionally.

 
Elbow crutches


Carved ivory handles from the Salar Jung Museum 

Image courtesy Wikimedia Commons

42 comments:

  1. Ha ha all very confusing! To be honest, I hadn't really thought about it!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It doesn't matter in the grand scheme of things!

      Delete
  2. Apparently I'm Anonymous lol. My silly blog signs me out every so often.

    ReplyDelete
  3. How fascinating! We call them sticks here too. I love the vintage ones & the rabbit (Hare) one at the end is really lovely. xx

    ReplyDelete
  4. You see many different kinds of sticks but you have sorted them out for us. I only use mine when I'm out walking and it's for balance. Nice post.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This is a remarkable post and could serve as an excellent reference for identifying the most suitable single-point cane for ambulation.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Well, they will always be sticks to me!

    ReplyDelete
  7. I have two 'canes' or whatever we prefer to call them, and I am certainly comfortable with 'stick' because I like all things British, it seems. When my leg really became wonky, particularly around the onset of the pandemic, I started to use a cane that Sue had after a mishap. The handle was a little too small, so I ordered another and have been using it ever since. I would like a nifty derby handle because they look snazzy, but I am doubtful about the grip working for me. Whatever I use, it is not all that exhilarating to "raise a little cane." But I now see that I have misunderstood that saying. I have thought it as having to do with a party of sorts, but, apparently, I have been wrong, which is just about the story of my life.

    "Behave in a rowdy or disruptive way, as in He said he'd raise Cain if they wouldn't give him a refund , or The gang was out to raise hell that night , or The wind raised the devil with our picnic . The first term alludes to the son of Adam and Eve who killed his brother, Abel."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We all like to 'raise Cain' now and again.
      The Derby handle looks smart but is not the best fit for stability, for me, anyway. I prefer the ergonomic handle. They feel very odd if you get them the wrong way round, like wearing shoes on the wrong feet!

      Delete
  8. It is true that we call walking sticks for the Trekkers that do the long hikes. When I needed a stick, it was an aluminum cane. Not very pretty but thankfully I only needed it for a couple of years. If I were a person that needed it forever I would want one of the beautiful wood ones with a carved handle. Whichever one you might be using, I just hope it gets you out and about.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We use walking (trekking) poles when we take the dogs out, as we go across rough ground.

      Delete
  9. Intricate terminology :) Being Swedish (and living in Sweden) with English as 2nd language, I tend to get stuck in this kind of research all the time, not sure what word to choose for something - especially since not even Brits vs Americans (etc) always agree... ;-) ... I have a foldable walking stick too, but what I use most (primarily in winter) I think are best known as walking poles. (I hesitate to call them hiking or trekking poles, as I usually just walk on flat ground in town...)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We use walking (trekking) poles all the time when we walk the dogs. Greater stability.

      Delete
  10. When I saw the title "Stick or cane?" I was looking forward to a blogpost about thrashing clients in a bordello. Perhaps there'd be Tory MPs involved. In the end, it was a comprehensive consideration of walking aids which to be frank was not quite as stimulating as the idea of leaving red weals on naughty Tory buttocks.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sorry to disappoint you, having titillated you with the title.
      Anyone can have naughty buttocks, or so I'm told.

      Delete
  11. All very interesting. I like the rabbit head handle on that last one.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I've been thinking about using walking poles recently. Love the carved head sticks x
    Alison in Wales x

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Walking poles give a great sense of security and stability, especially on rough terrain. We use them all the time in the woods.

      Delete
  13. yet again we find all of this down what I call the rabbit hole of the internet. when I ask a simple question, like this one thing lead to another and another. until today. I knew a walking cane was for people who need a little support and walking sticks are the long tall straight poles that people us when hiking, one in each hand. that was it.
    now, IF I retain this I know a lot more. I did because I read so much no what a shillelagh is. I am now more than familiar with a WALKER and no sticks or canes involved.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. A walker is the most stable of all walking aids, but one without the wheels!!

      Delete
  14. I like the term walking stick myself. The one that looks like a bow and arrow but is a seat seems both uncomfortable and dangerous.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I'm never very comfortable on a shooting stick, but it's better than nothing if you want a quick perch outside.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Interesting. My father had walking sticks with a horse head, snake head, and I think an eagle.

    ReplyDelete
  17. How lovely. I'd love a carved stick.

    ReplyDelete
  18. My brother in law's wife has quite the collection of walking sticks (carved from wood, mostly) which she uses if she is out on a nature trail. When my husband used a cane it was for balance and he used it on city sidewalks. It's interesting to see the variations in the English language between my country (the United States) and other countries where English is the primary language.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Two countries divided by a common language!

      Delete
  19. We call them canes where I live.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. So long as they do the job, it doesn't matter what they're called. 😀

      Delete
  20. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  21. What a wide variety of walking aids! I'm using a walking/trekking pole as well. I would generally consider a walking stick to be straight at the top and a walking cane to have a bent top, candy can like! xxx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've noticed your walking pole on your blog. Essential where you walk.

      Delete
  22. I tend to call them walking sticks or walking poles.
    Really though, whatever they are called it is important to have the right one for you. Comfort and balance for this, at times, very important aid.

    Another great post full of information, thank you.

    All the best Jan

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I am surprised that I don't see more people using them in the woods.

      Delete
  23. I use a walker with two handles, 4 small wheels and a mesh seat. I checked out all the canes you mentioned, but they didn't give any balance.

    ReplyDelete
  24. It's good that you've found something that suits you.

    ReplyDelete
  25. The carved handles are real pieces of art but I don't know if they would be practical to use. I prefer the ergonomic handles and adjustable height ones. I also still have a couple of elbow crutches somewhere and a carved cane which belonged to my dad.

    ReplyDelete



Thank you for visiting. I love to read your comments and really appreciate you taking the time to respond to posts.

I will always try to repay your visit whenever possible.