Wednesday, 4 October 2023

Mushroom or Fungus?

 

Mushroom or Fungus?

All mushrooms are fungi but not all fungi are mushrooms. Fungi include moulds, yeasts and rusts. All fungi differ from plants and animals in the way they obtain their sustenance. They cannot ingest food like animals or photosynthesise like plants. They ‘feed’ by absorbing nutrients from the environment, decomposing organic matter, which becomes compost.

The fungi commonly called mushrooms grow all year round but are most noticeable in late summer and early autumn.

 
Not all mushrooms grow low down. Chicken of the Woods (Laetiporus sulphureus) grows on tree trunks, notably oak trees and can be seen from late spring to autumn. It is valuable for wildlife. Some beetles only feed on bracket fungi like this one. Deer eat it, too.

 Humans can eat Chicken of the Woods but it can cause dizziness and stomach upsets in some people. It is poisonous if growing on yew. It is said to have a texture similar to chicken when cooked, so is an acceptable substitute for meat in vegetarian meals.

 
Orange Peel Fungus (Aleuria (Peziza) aurantia)

This edible fungus grows on open ground in woods and is very common in autumn. It starts as very small cups, looking flat, but grows to 3-4" across. 

From August to November walking with the dogs in the woodlands takes on a new aspect. Silent figures in ones or twos may be seen, causing warning barks or excited approaches, depending on the character of the dogs. The objects of their interest walk quietly among the trees, eyes cast down, frequently stooping to gather something from the rich soil. 

They may emerge suddenly from the cover of the woods, holding plastic bags weighed down with their booty. Occasionally, they carry shallow baskets. These folk are the mushroom seekers, the amateur but very knowledgeable mycologists, for at this time of year the earth gives up an abundance of mushrooms. 

 
think this is Brown Birch Boletus (Boletus scaber) - but I could be wrong!!

It is quite common in summer and autumn in woods around birch trees.  The caps are edible and good to eat but the stalks are rather tough.

English people have little folklore about mushrooms and many of the tests to decide which ones are edible and which poisonous are not to be trusted. They may well grow in grass or not blacken a silver spoon but these are dangerously ill-informed methods for testing the toxicity or otherwise of them.

 In Europe the knowledge is deeply ingrained, with France having perhaps the greatest interest and understanding. Until the Second World War Englishmen were very suspicious of wild mushrooms but learnt much from immigrant Poles and other Europeans who taught them that some toadstools can be delicious. Others, though edible, are so bland as to be not worth eating.

 The most prized fungi of all, the truffles, do not generally grow in UK, but when they do they are mostly found under beech trees. In France they usually grow under evergreen oaks. Specially trained pigs or dogs are used to sniff out the wondrous treats that develop underground, often at a depth of a foot or more. 

 Since the end of the Second World War, interest in the UK in collecting mushrooms has grown and is causing some concern, because mushrooms are very important in maintaining moisture in the soil and providing a source of water for trees. In times of extended periods of dry weather such water caches are invaluable. 



This is one of my favourite books. The glorious illustrations are by Beatrix Potter

Fly agaric (Amanita muscaria) is a striking mushroom often seen in children's books. In Alice in Wonderland Alice is given fly agaric to eat. For more than 4,000 years it was used in religious ceremonies in Asia. It is hallucinogenic. 

Just as scavenging birds and beasts  keep the world largely free of decaying carcases, so fungi perform a similarly significant service. Indeed, they have been described as ‘the great scavengers of the vegetable kingdom.' (‘Wayside and Woodland Fungi’, W.P.K. Findlay D.Sc., F.I.Biol., F.I.W.Sc)

Trametes (formerly Coriolus) versicolor, commonly called Turkey Tail in USA

This is very common on fallen branches and trunks. It is a medicinal mushroom in China and used in China and Japan as an immunoadjuvant therapy in the treatment of cancer.

  Together with bacteria mushrooms break down organic detritus. Without them the world would be cluttered with dead trees, fallen branches and deep, deep leaf drifts. The enzymes they produce liquefy the wood of trees and the soft tissues of leaves and fruits to provide nourishment for the fungi. Anything that is not consumed forms rich humus on the forest floor and acts as a sponge to retain moisture. Some fungi are adapted to decomposing hoof and hair remains of animals.

 Fungi are a source of food, drugs, poisons and diseases. They cause most of the serious plant ailments and some that are troublesome to man and animal, like ringworm. Every gardener who maintains a compost heap owes its success in part to moulds as well as bacteria and worms.

 If you should feel inclined to eat wild fungi please don’t rely on identification through illustrations. Toxic and non-toxic mushrooms can look remarkably similar and a simple mistake can lead at best to several hours’ discomfort and at worst to an agonising death. Take advice from a knowledgeable mycologist and if in doubt, DON’T!

21 comments:

  1. A couple of months ago, three people at a dinner party in rural Victoria ate mushrooms in a beef dish and died in agony. A fourth was in hospital for a very long time and survived. Now I wonder why we had never been told the material in your post before.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The information has always been available. I think many people have been caught up in foraging and like the idea of eating off the land. simple enough when it's blackberries or sloes but mushrooms are too tricky.

      Delete
  2. I'll be safe and always buy my mushrooms from the supermarket.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Edible forms of mushrooms are quite common in India. A choice of many people in restaurants and homes. People say they have high levels of anti-oxidants. But it's not among my top choices at the dining table.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mushrooms don't agree with me so I never eat them, but I'd be very wary of 'wild' varieties.

      Delete
  4. Here in the north of Scotland I note that the majority of those foraging for edible mushrooms are from our immigrant East European population. In the birch grove behind my Torridon cottage, I am lucky to have available a prolific (and delicious) annual crop of chanterelles.
    Nobby only shows a limited interest in fungi, which is perhaps a good thing.
    Cheers, Gail.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You are fortunate in having a private supply:-)

      Delete
  5. I'm hoping to see some attractive fungi when we walk around the forest this morning. There should be. Fingers crossed. xx

    ReplyDelete
  6. Fungi are rather interesting and as a city dweller I rarely see any that aren't on a shelf for sale. On our farm when I was young, we often picked mushrooms but only the one kind. I never liked eating them. One year my brother and I had picked so many we set up a roadside stall. We had money change and paper bags to put the sold mushrooms into, along with a large painted sign. The first man who stopped bought the lot. We were so disappointed at not being able to play greengrocers for a few hours.

    I really used to like seeing fungi and moss growing on trees.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's funny, but how disappointing for two young entrepreneurs!

      Delete
  7. I do love mushrooms, or toadstools if you so wish...
    So l know what and what not to eat...On the medical
    side of course...They are a rich, low-calorie source of
    fiber, protein, and antioxidants...
    They may also help to lessen the risk of developing
    serious health conditions, such as Alzheimer's, heart
    disease, cancer, and diabetes...

    And your right about the ID of the Brown Birch Boletus,
    Brown Birch Boletus...
    Appearing under birch trees, this summer and autumn
    Bolete is one that even inexperienced fungi foragers
    are unlikely to confuse with any of the dangerously
    poisonous gilled mushrooms...!
    🍄 🍄 🍄 🍄 🍄 🍄 🍄 🍄 🍄 🍄 🍄 🍄 🍄 🍄

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I would never have the confidence to pick wild mushrooms - one mistake could be fatal.

      Delete
  8. Love mushrooms this time of year. I love eating them too. B x

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I used to love mushrooms but they don't agree with me any more. My friends and I used to buy them and eat them raw while we waited for the bus after school.

      Delete
  9. I used to stay with German Friends in Berlin many moons ago and they foraged for mushrooms in the forest where they lived. Their knowledge was extensive but if they found one they couldn't identify or be sure of they took it to am Apotheke (pharmacy).

    ReplyDelete
  10. That is such a sensible thing to do - I wonder if our pharmacists would be as knowledgeable.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Thanks for an informative post! I'd be afraid to eat any wild mushrooms. You really have to know them well to feel safe ingesting them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's so easy to confuse toxic and non-toxic unless you've been trained from an early age to distinguish between them.

      Delete
  12. I find mushrooms fascinating, but other than admiring and photographing them, I know very little about them. I'm also very ignorant as to their names - apart from the ubiquitous fly agaric - so it's nice to be able to match some names to the ones I keep seeing around! xxx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They are really interesting to study. It's sad when beautiful mushrooms are knocked over 'for fun'. People don't realise how valuable they are. x x x

      Delete



Thank you for visiting. I love to read your comments and really appreciate you taking the time to respond to posts.

I will always try to repay your visit whenever possible.