More superstitions
Image courtesy of Wikimedia Commons
Hels and Andrew both mentioned superstitions I have often pondered.
Hels spoke of the bad luck that will befall anyone who opens an umbrella indoors. She said, ’The only superstition that sounded even vaguely sensible to me was never to open an umbrella in the house. I suppose it MIGHT have poked a family member in the eye.’
That’s certainly
the understanding I had.
In "Extraordinary Origins of Everyday Things" (Harper, 1989), the scientist and author Charles Panati wrote: "In eighteenth-century London, when metal-spoked waterproof umbrellas began to become a common rainy-day sight, their stiff, clumsy spring mechanism made them veritable hazards to open indoors. A rigidly spoked umbrella, opening suddenly in a small room, could seriously injure an adult or a child, or shatter a frangible object. Even a minor accident could provoke unpleasant words or a minor quarrel, themselves strokes of bad luck in a family or among friends. Thus, the superstition arose as a deterrent to opening an umbrella indoors."
Another suggestion for the origin of the superstition says that in Ancient Egypt, umbrellas were used as protection from the heat and were thought to ward off evil spirits. Opening an umbrella indoors, out of the sun, would be an insult to the sun god, Ra, and promote unfavourable consequences.
Andrew mentioned the myth that new shoes should not be put on the table. He said, ’My partner yells at me to remove them, so I don't do it.’
I’ve always thought this a really odd superstition. I could only think it might be because the shoes might scratch the table and that putting shoes on the table might become an unwelcome habit.
I looked it up and found that it is considered bad luck in many English-speaking countries. At a time when shoes were very expensive, before the advent of modern machinery in the 19th century they would be passed on from a dead donor and would therefore be ‘new’ to the recipient. Thus putting ‘new’ shoes on the table could signify the death of someone or simply bring bad luck for the rest of the day.
In the North of England, after a colliery accident, a dead miner’s shoes would be put on the table as a sign of respect, so to put ‘ordinary’ shoes there would be considered bad taste as well as tempting fate.
In 1814, the Duke of Wellington had noticed many officers carrying umbrellas to shelter from the rain. Wellington made it clear that he did not approve of their use in battle, saying, ‘in the field it is not only ridiculous but unmilitary.’ Standing orders for the Battle of Waterloo stated unequivocally, ‘Umbrellas will not be opened in the presence of the enemy.’
My mum would never allow new shoes on the table either. Another of her superstitions is to never give knives as a gift, the recipient should pay a small coin like a penny, to avoid "cutting the friendship". I remember her giving me a one cent coin to "buy" the set of knives she bought for my glory box.
ReplyDeleteI remember the knives superstition. My mother told me it out of interest - she was not a superstitious woman.
DeleteMy grandmother was not a particular superstitious woman but she wanted us to _never_ name a new baby with a name of a close relative who was still alive. Apparently when the Angel of Death comes to earth to look for elderly, fragile and sick Fred, he might take the wrong (baby) Fred by mistake. Thus we never ever re-used the name of a person who was still alive.
ReplyDeleteThat is fascinating. I've never heard that superstition before. Actually, in earlier times, in England, when many infants died, subsequent children were given their names, so it wasn't a belief held in this country.
ReplyDeleteYou should do a series on superstitions - there are dozens that we could describe - passed on a a matter of interest rather than strict belief by older members of our families.
ReplyDeleteYou read my mind! I'd be interested in your collection.
DeleteWhat is really amazing is that many of these superstitions continue even into the modern era when we know that there is no basis for them. Despite technology we cling to old beliefs, I suppose.
ReplyDeleteThey are a form of comfort to many - that's fine so long as they don't overwhelm common sense.
DeleteYes, not opening an umbrella indoors is another of my partner's suspicions, so don't. One last one, you can't give a knife as a gift. You need to pay the giver at least a penny or cent.
ReplyDeleteMy mother told me that one, out of interest.
DeleteMy mom was always quoting some old suspiration like these. I wish she hadn't because they are still stuck in my head. Such as, don't go out one door and come in another. That one gets me all the time.
ReplyDeleteIt's annoying when they don't make any sense at all but you still keep hearing them in your head.
DeleteInteresting! I've heard of the umbrella superstition, but not of the shoes. I wonder if shoes in their boxes count as well, as there are currently two boxes on our dining room table, containing new shoes my husband bought on holiday ... I think I'll nip downstairs and remove them just in case :-) xxx
ReplyDeleteBetter to be safe than sorry! x x
DeleteHi Janice - I love the Duke's dictat! too many superstitions to be remembered perhaps - some make absolute sense. Cheers Hilary
ReplyDeleteIt would have looked ludicrous to carry an umbrella in battle, particularly on horseback! x
ReplyDelete